260922 – Grand Rounds – Persisting Symptoms After Concussion

Get Up and Get Moving:

Notes on Dr. Thayer White’s Grand Rounds on Persisting Symptoms After Concussion

By Thomas Lee Abshier, ND | 22 September 2026

Watch the original lecture: Persisting Symptoms After Concussion — Providence Medical Grand Rounds, September 22, 2026. Providence Grand Rounds video playlist

Why I am writing about this lecture

I attend Providence Medical Grand Rounds for my continuing medical education, and I am grateful that Providence offers these sessions in person, live online, and by recording. Grand Rounds is a joint effort of Providence St. Vincent and Providence Portland Medical Centers; this session was held live at St. Vincent.

The speaker was Dr. Thayer White, who practices primary care and sports medicine at the Providence Medical Group Gleason Clinic in Northeast Portland. He completed his family medicine residency and sports medicine fellowship at OHSU, serves as chief medical officer for the Portland Timbers, is a physician for the Portland Trail Blazers, and is a team physician for Grant High School. He described himself, with good humor, as an outpatient east-side family physician who is not a regular at Grand Rounds. His lecture was practical, clear, honest about the limits of the evidence, and full of advice any clinician can use the next day.

What follows is my organized summary of the lecture, with my own commentary in a clearly marked section. I have paraphrased throughout; any errors are mine, not Dr. White’s. I encourage every clinician, and anyone who has struggled after a head injury, to watch the lecture itself.

In brief. After a concussion, rest for a day or so, then get moving. The old advice to retreat to a dark room until symptoms vanish (“cocooning”) is now known to slow recovery. Light daily exercise, an early return to school or work, good sleep, and a clinician who listens and says “I can help you” make the difference. For people still struggling after about four weeks, the problem is often less a damaged brain than a sensitized nervous system, much like chronic low back pain, and it responds to the same active, rebuilding approach, supported by targeted therapy for headaches, vision, balance, and sleep.

Why the name “persisting symptoms after concussion”

Dr. White explained that the field now favors the term persisting symptoms after concussion over post-concussion syndrome. The new name says only what we know: there was a head injury, and symptoms remain. Whether those symptoms come from a still-injured brain or from other causes is still debated and researched. Either way, there is much we can do both to prevent persisting symptoms and to treat them.

His motive for giving the talk was practical. Patients usually reach him three to six months after their injury, after they have wound their way through the system. By then they are often “locked in,” and he must undo a good deal of what they have learned to fear. If every clinician handled the first days well, many of these patients would never need him. (For Providence clinicians, he noted the Epic referral “PMG Sports Care”; that patients with symptoms longer than a year or who are over 65 receive a brief review to confirm sports medicine is the right fit; that chronic headache can be a good reason for neurology referral; and that MedPearl, linked from Epic, carries concussion guidance consistent with his talk. Sports medicine works on a consultation model: assess, plan, refer, follow up once or twice.)

The case: a patient lost in the system

Dr. White built the talk around a real patient he saw the previous winter, presented with care and without blame.

A healthy 55-year-old man struck his head hard on a basement beam in September. He was dazed but not knocked out. He had no prior concussions and perhaps one migraine. Dr. White always asks about migraines, because people with a strong migraine history tend to have longer, more symptomatic recoveries. The patient had also been under real stress, working long unpaid hours since February to launch an online business, with occasional poor sleep, though he felt good about his life and was functioning well. His primary care physician had left the practice, and he did not know who his new one was.

Day two, urgent care. He received printed instructions to rest his brain: dark room, avoid stimulation, do nothing until symptoms resolve. Dr. White noted, without rancor, that this is exactly how he himself was trained 15 or 16 years ago. The field calls it cocooning, and the evidence now shows it sets people up for trouble.

One to two weeks later, express care. Nothing in the note was wrong, but what the patient heard was, in effect: not much to do, it doesn’t seem that bad, walk it off, come back if you don’t improve. He left without hope.

A few weeks later, the emergency department. After a minor second bump, he became frightened and went to the ER. The CT scan was normal. The physician’s note suggested the right advice (stay active), but the templated discharge instructions again warned him to rest his brain and that head injury can cause severe neurologic problems.

Two months in. He was in occupational therapy, which helped somewhat. He sent a portal message asking whether he could keep taking acetaminophen for his daily headaches and was told he could, within the labeled dose. Dr. White observed that this was a missed opportunity: two months of daily headaches should prompt an invitation to come in and figure out what is going on.

The turning point. Desperate, he saw a craniosacral therapist. Dr. White noted that this patient is not someone inclined toward alternative care (adding, “not that there’s anything wrong with” that). What struck the patient was that it was the first time anyone had told him, I can help you. He felt better than he had in two months and continued seeing that therapist. He then sought out vestibular physical therapy, neuro-optometry (which provided prism lenses to correct eye-teaming problems common after concussion), and a neuro-audiologist, a specialty Dr. White admitted he had not known existed.

Five months in, sports medicine. When Dr. White saw him in February, the man had just resumed driving after four months. He had worked eight to ten hours a day before; now he managed a couple of hours. He spent an hour or two daily on therapy exercises and walks, still took acetaminophen or ibuprofen daily, and had not returned to the gym, motorcycling, kayaking, or skiing. He was not disabled, but his life had shrunk dramatically from one bump on the head.

What a concussion is

The formal sport-related concussion definition is long. Dr. White noted that about 90% of concussion research comes from athletes, because that is where the funding is (the NFL and FIFA invest heavily), with most of the rest from the military. So we assume, reasonably but with caution, that the findings apply to a 55-year-old man who hit his head in his basement.

He distilled the definition into four points:

  1. There must be a force to the brain. Without one, it is not a concussion. He has seen patients referred for concussion symptoms who never had a head injury.
  2. Symptoms appear within 72 hours, usually immediately. The window allows for people distracted by other injuries.
  3. Standard imaging is normal. CT and MRI are often appropriate to exclude other problems but do not show concussion.
  4. Symptoms are many and nonspecific, overlapping with countless other causes of fatigue, headache, and fogginess. So the evaluation must also look for other causes.

His summary: a concussion is a complex, poorly understood condition that is distressing to patients and occurs in the biopsychosocial context of their messy and complicated lives. That might make clinicians want to run, but, he argued, this is exactly what primary care does. People are not textbooks, and we do our best to understand and care for them.

The first days and weeks

Evaluation. Do a careful neurologic exam to exclude focal findings. Beyond the first 48 hours, when deteriorating mental status is unlikely, consider simple balance testing and a vestibular-ocular check: smooth pursuit, saccades, and nystagmus. Vestibular-ocular dysfunction is especially common in patients who do not recover quickly.

Treatment: like any musculoskeletal injury. Dr. White’s central analogy was low back pain. We once told people with back strain to lie on the couch, and then learned that staying active and getting into physical therapy helps them recover faster. Concussion turned out to be exactly the same. Take a day or so to take it easy, avoid another blow to the head (no returning to the football game), and then get up and get moving.

The evidence, he said, is strongest for:

  • Early, low-intensity, low-impact exercise, such as walking or cycling. Randomized trials comparing early with delayed activity favor early activity clearly, and the effect appears causal rather than simply reflecting milder injuries.
  • An early return to school or work. The longer someone waits, the worse the long-term recovery. Some patients need a gentle push.

The evidence is weaker for:

  • Sleep interventions. Poor sleep correlates with worse recovery, but no specific intervention has been proven to help. He still teaches sleep hygiene, since it carries little risk.
  • Screen-time limits. He found the supporting data weak: studies mostly took phones away from teenagers until they “felt better,” which, he noted dryly, may have motivated rapid recovery. He does not encourage heavy screen use, but it is not worth a long argument.

When to refer. Earlier is better. If symptoms persist beyond about a week (headache, fogginess, not feeling right), start referrals to physical or occupational therapy, because getting in takes time.

When symptoms persist

Dr. White places patients in the persisting-symptoms category at about four weeks with symptoms above their baseline. (Because “persisting symptoms after concussion” is not an ICD-10 code, he still uses “post-concussion” for billing.) Baseline matters: he asked the audience how many were at zero on a concussion symptom scale right now. Even healthy high school students average a score of about 6 to 8, so there is no single cutoff; what counts is change from the person’s own baseline.

The visit: listen first

These are long visits, 40 minutes or more, compared with 15 minutes for a knee. He listens for:

  • Fears about activities, and what the patient has been told to avoid
  • Whether he believes his brain is damaged, or that he is an injured person who may never recover
  • What he has been told, and by whom
  • What is going well, so progress can be named and reframed (“You’re driving again. Isn’t that great?”)
  • Medications and supplements, especially daily acetaminophen or ibuprofen. Medication-overuse headache is very common. Stopping analgesics for a week or two often helps a great deal, though headaches worsen for a few days first, and getting patients through that is a challenge.
  • Previous concussions and how those recoveries went
  • Migraine, headache, and other neurologic history
  • Visual symptoms, which nearly all persisting patients have: tired eyes with screens, trouble reading, difficulty tracking motion, blurring, light sensitivity

The exam and the workup

His exam is brief and focused: balance testing; smooth pursuits and saccades, using a finger or tongue depressor, to see whether the eyes move together and hit their targets; and orthostatic vital signs if dizziness is prominent, since there is overlap with orthostatic intolerance. He also makes sure other causes have been considered: head imaging if symptoms have lasted months; an MRI of the internal auditory canals if dizziness or vertigo is prominent; basic labs as symptoms suggest; and possibly a sleep study. He has found sleep apnea in patients whose main complaint was fatigue, with a dramatic difference once it was treated. Pre-existing conditions and medication side effects belong on the list too.

Reframing: from protecting the brain to rebuilding it

The long listening has a purpose. Dr. White wants patients to believe he cares and understands, so that they will trust what he says next. He does not tell anyone, “Your brain is fine, walk it off.” As he put it, you don’t calm someone down by telling him to calm down; you have to circle around it.

But his working view, and the emerging consensus among experts, is that the physical changes of concussion have probably healed in nearly everyone by about three months. Many patients beyond that point have learned behaviors and central sensitization, the same process seen in chronic pain, where tissue heals but the nervous system stays hyperreactive. He offers patients phrases such as: your brain has been injured and now needs to rebuild its connections; it has to be strengthened again; we are not protecting your brain anymore, we are pushing it and strengthening it, and it is time to put in the work.

The four pillars of recovery

  1. Daily exercise. Of all interventions studied, it is the only one that consistently speeds recovery; everything else manages symptoms. It need not be vigorous. A daily walk, preferably outdoors moving through the world rather than on a treadmill, is ideal. If an activity provokes symptoms, back off and go lighter rather than stop.
  2. Optimized sleep. Strict sleep hygiene, with the same bedtime and wake time seven days a week where work allows, plus simple CBT-for-insomnia techniques. He sometimes suggests low-dose melatonin or magnesium (which he doubts makes a large difference), nortriptyline (also useful for headache prevention), or occasionally trazodone. None of this differs from good insomnia care generally.
  3. Symptom management, so patients can function while they recover: medications where useful, aids such as earplugs and tinted lenses, and referral to concussion-trained physical, occupational, and speech therapists, who are available at most Providence clinics.
  4. Resuming meaningful activities. “Yeah, go kayaking,” even if it is hard and not the way it used to be. Don’t keep life on pause out of fear of the injury.

Matching treatment to symptoms

Dr. White shared a Providence Sports Medicine reference slide for symptom-specific care, noting that not every patient needs every referral. The art is choosing.

  • Headache. Refer to neurology for chronic post-traumatic headache, especially in patients with a prior migraine history whose migraines have increased, who may be candidates for Botox. Physical therapy helps the large share of headaches driven by neck pain and cervicogenic referral. Among supplements, butterbur has some decent evidence. For prevention, topiramate and beta blockers are often poorly tolerated by patients who are already tired and dizzy, so he favors nortriptyline, which causes less nausea and dry mouth than amitriptyline, starting at 10 mg and titrating by 10 mg steps.
  • Cognition. First ask about regular alcohol and marijuana use and gently draw the connection. Consider depression and sleep apnea. Stimulants have been studied and do not help concussion-related cognitive symptoms outside of ADHD.
  • Fatigue. Again, exercise and sleep. He rarely uses modafinil.
  • Dizziness. Involve vestibular therapists. Head trauma can injure the inner ear, so for persistent dizziness he often orders an MRI of the internal auditory canals and refers to ENT; he noted Oregon Clinic ENTs with particular skill in dizziness. Medications play a limited role.
  • Light and sound sensitivity. Specialized concussion earplugs reduce sound by roughly 10 to 15 decibels while still allowing hearing; tinted (yellow or blue-blocking) lenses or screen filters can help those who must use screens. Patients who arrive wearing two pairs of sunglasses and a hat need a conversation about gradually coming out of the dark.
  • Return to work. Accommodations are individual and could fill another talk. Shift workers may face an all-or-nothing choice, while salaried workers can often step back to one or two days a week. The goal is to find what is possible, so that the patient does not sit at home feeling worse.

From the question period

What is the level of evidence? A physician recalled being taught cocooning by an expert long ago, likely based on opinion alone, and asked whether the new approach rests on better evidence. Dr. White said early return to activity and exercise is supported by randomized trials and is the recommendation he is comfortable “hanging his hat on”: take it easy for about 24 hours, then be as active as you can. Much of the rest rests on smaller and cohort studies, somewhat better than expert opinion, with a few items at the expert-opinion level.

What about fear of another head injury? If the patient is beyond the first three months, Dr. White is not worried that another bump will cause catastrophic harm, but it could raise symptoms and set back recovery. So he negotiates: shooting baskets with a friend is fine; aggressive five-on-five play should wait until the patient feels recovered. Once a patient is back to baseline, there are no lifelong restrictions. Patients with many concussions (say, eight) need an individual conversation, and he welcomes those referrals.

“I can help you.” The moderator highlighted the patient’s remark that the craniosacral therapist was the first to say “I can help.” In complex conditions, she noted, clinicians need to signpost clearly what they are doing. Dr. White agreed. Reassurance that a condition will not kill you is not enough; clinicians should address the underlying concern and give patients something active to do.

Adaptive equipment and neuro-optometry. Dr. White almost always refers patients with significant visual symptoms to neuro-optometry, a small specialty in Portland (two small private practices and OHSU), often not covered by the Oregon Health Plan unless motor-vehicle insurance applies. Most Providence occupational therapists offer basic vision therapy as an alternative for those who cannot get in.

My reflections

This section is my own commentary, not part of the lecture.

This lecture was a model of what Grand Rounds can be: grounded in a real patient, generous toward every clinician in the story, candid about what is and is not known, and full of advice one can use tomorrow. Dr. White’s willingness to say that the cocooning advice was how he himself was trained, and that the field has learned better, is the kind of intellectual honesty that makes a teacher trustworthy.

Three lessons stay with me.

First, the body heals by doing. The movement from “rest your brain” to “get up and get moving” mirrors what medicine learned about back pain and, before that, about many other injuries. As a naturopathic physician, I have always placed movement, fresh air, sunlight, and sleep at the foundation of healing. It is gratifying to see randomized trials confirm that a daily walk outdoors, preferably moving through the world rather than on a treadmill, is the single intervention that most reliably speeds concussion recovery.

Second, hope is part of the treatment. The most moving moment of the case was the patient’s report that months passed before anyone told him, I can help you. Dr. White and the moderator both drew the right lesson: patients need to be heard, to have their concern addressed, and to leave with something active to do. Fear and the belief that one is permanently injured can sustain symptoms long after tissue heals. Words are powerful medicine, for good or ill, and printed discharge instructions are words too.

Third, fit the care to the person. Dr. White’s emphasis on baselines, on asking about migraine history, stress, sleep, alcohol, marijuana, and daily analgesics, and on choosing among many possible referrals rather than sending everyone everywhere, reflects the truth that concussion happens, as he put it, in the messy and complicated context of real lives. That is a principle for all of medicine.

I am grateful to Dr. White for a lecture that was practical, humane, and refreshingly clear, and to Providence for continuing a Grand Rounds tradition that brings this kind of teaching to clinicians across the region. Please watch the original.

A practical guide drawn from the lecture

In the first days after a concussion:

  • Take it easy for about 24 hours, and avoid any activity that risks another blow to the head.
  • Then resume normal daily activities as much as possible, backing off from anything that clearly worsens symptoms.
  • Walk or ride a stationary bike daily at an easy, comfortable intensity.
  • Return to school or work early, with temporary accommodations if needed.
  • Keep a regular sleep schedule.
  • Do not retreat to a dark room “until it’s gone.”

For clinicians, if symptoms last beyond a week:

  • Start PT or OT referrals early; they take time.
  • Make sure patient instructions match the advice you actually give.

If symptoms last beyond four weeks:

  • Schedule a long visit; listen for fears and beliefs about injury.
  • Ask about migraine history, prior concussions, sleep, stress, alcohol, marijuana, and daily analgesic use.
  • Check balance, eye movements, and orthostatics if dizzy.
  • Rule out other causes: imaging, labs, sleep apnea, medication effects.
  • Reframe from protecting the brain to rebuilding it.
  • Prescribe daily exercise, sleep hygiene, and symptom-targeted therapy (vestibular, vision, neck, headache).
  • Encourage a return to the activities the patient loves.

Editorial notes

These notes clarify points from the lecture for readers who want to follow up. They are mine, not the speaker’s.

  • The SCAT. The transcript expands SCAT as “Sideline Concussion Assessment Test.” Its formal name is the Sport Concussion Assessment Tool; the current version, SCAT6, was updated at the 2022 Amsterdam consensus conference. Its symptom scale rates 22 symptoms from 0 to 6 (1–2 mild, 3–4 moderate, 5–6 severe). An office version, the SCOAT6, is designed for evaluation in the clinic.
  • International consensus. The Consensus Statement on Concussion in Sport from the Sixth International Conference (Amsterdam, October 2022; British Journal of Sports Medicine, 2023) states that strict rest is not recommended, cites stronger evidence for light-intensity exercise within the first 48 hours, and advises multidisciplinary assessment for symptoms lasting more than four weeks, matching Dr. White’s thresholds. The statement also advises limiting screen use in the first 48 hours; Dr. White’s remark about weak screen-time data concerns longer restrictions, and readers may wish to note both views.
  • Exercise trial. A key randomized trial (Leddy et al., JAMA Pediatrics 2019) assigned 103 adolescent athletes seen within 10 days of a sport-related concussion to subsymptom-threshold aerobic exercise or a placebo-like stretching program; the exercise group recovered faster.
  • Butterbur safety. Butterbur (Petasites hybridus) has trial evidence for migraine prevention, but raw plant material contains pyrrolizidine alkaloids that can injure the liver. The American Academy of Neurology retired its earlier Level A recommendation in 2015 over safety concerns. Anyone considering butterbur should use only products certified free of pyrrolizidine alkaloids (“PA-free”), under a clinician’s guidance, with liver monitoring as appropriate.
  • Patient details. Dr. White presented his case without identifying information. I have kept the clinic types general.

Sources

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *